| 1868 | James P. WHITNEY | |
| 1869 | John Frederick MORSE, Sr. | |
| 1870 | Henry GIBBONS, Sr. | |
| 1871 | Benjamin D. DEAN | |
| 1872 | John Frederick MORSE, Sr. | |
| 1873 | Arthur G. SOULE | |
| 1874 | William A. GROVER | |
| 1875 | Henry GIBBONS, Sr. | |
| 1876 | Phelps CHAMBERLAIN | |
| 1877 | Washington AYER | |
| 1878 | C.N. ELLINWOOD | |
| 1879 | Curtis G. KENYON | |
| 1880 | R.H. PLUMMER | |
| 1881 | Oscar O. BURGESS | |
| 1882 | William H. MAYS | |
| 1883 | Joseph O. HIRSCHFELDER | |
| 1884 | William G. WHITWELL | |
| 1885 | James Gray JEWELL | |
| 1886 | William E. TAYLOR | |
| 1887 | James SIMPSON | |
| 1888 | Josiah D. ARNOLD | |
| 1889 | George CHISMORE | |
| 1890 | John F. MORSE, Jr. | |
| 1891 | A.P. WHITTELL | |
| 1892 | Douglass W. MONTGOMERY | |
| 1893 | H.H. HART | |
| 1894 | William Watt KERR | |
| 1895 | C.C. WADSWORTH | |
| 1896 | William Fitch CHENEY | |
| 1897 | Frank B. CARPENTER | |
| 1898 | A.P. WOODWARD | |
| 1899 | George W. DAVIS | |
| 1900 | Elmer E. KELLY | |
| 1901 | George H. EVANS | |
| 1902 | John C. SPENCER | |
| 1903 | Louis A. KENGLA | |
| 1904 | Julius ROSENSTIRN | |
| 1905 | Emmet RIXFORD | |
| 1906 | Wallace I. TERRY | |
| 1907 | J. Henry BARBAR | |
| 1908 | Charles G. LEVISON | |
| 1909 | August J. LARTIGAU | |
| 1910 | Langley PORTER | |
| 1911 | William OPHULS | |
| 1912 | F. Dudley TAIT | |
| 1913 | Henry B.A. KUGELER | |
| 1914 | Arthur A. O'NEILL | |
| 1915 | Herbert C. MOFFITT | |
| 1916 | Cullen F. WELTY | |
| 1917 | Artillio H. GIANNINI | |
| 1918 | John H. GRAVES | |
| 1919 | Reginald Knight SMITH | |
| 1920 | Harry E. ALDERSON | |
| 1921 | Morton R. GIBBONS | |
| 1922 | Saxton Temple POPE | |
| 1923 | Sol HYMAN | |
| 1924 | Emmet RIXFORD | |
| 1925 | LeRoy H. BRIGGS | |
| 1926 | Frank HINMAN, Sr. | |
| 1927 | Alfred J. ZOBEL | |
| 1928 | Alexander S. KEENAN | |
| 1929 | Howard C. NATFZIGER | |
| 1930 | Harold K. FABER | |
| 1931 | Charles P. MATHE | |
| 1932 | Alson R. KILGORE | |
| 1933 | Karl L. SCHAUPP | |
| 1934 | Isaac W. THORNE | |
| 1935 | Jacob C. GEIGER | |
| 1936 | Philip K. GILMAN | |
| 1937 | T. Henshaw KELLY | |
| 1938 | William C. VOORSANGER | |
| 1939 | Edwin L. BRUCK | |
| 1940 | William REILLY | |
| 1941 | Harold A. FLETCHER | |
| 1942 | John W. CLINE | |
| 1943 | Sidney J. SHIPMAN | |
| 1944 | Stanley H. MENTZER | |
| 1945 | G. Dan DELPRAT | |
| 1946 | Chester L. COOLEY | |
| 1947 | Anthony B. DIEPENBROCK | |
| 1948 | Robertson WARD | |
| 1949 | Ivan C. HERON | |
| 1950 | William L. BENDER | |
| 1951 | Garnett CHENEY | |
| 1952 | Stacy R. METTIER | |
| 1953 | Edmund J. MORRISSEY | |
| 1954 | Samuel R. SHERMAN | |
| 1955 | Herbert C. MOFFITT, Jr. | |
| 1956 | Matthew N.. HOSMER | |
| 1957 | Donald M. CAMPBELL | |
| 1958 | Robert C. COMBS | |
| 1959 | Claude P. CALLAWAY | |
| 1960 | Roberta FENLON | |
| 1961 | Malcolm S.M. WATTS | |
| 1962 | Eugene M. WEBB | |
| 1963 | A. Justin WILLIAMS | |
| 1964 | John B. SCHAUPP | |
| 1965 | Edgar WAYBURN | |
| 1966 | George K. HERZOG, Jr. | |
| 1967 | Albert G. CLARK | |
| 1968 | Henry GIBBONS, III | |
| 1969 | Sanford E. FELDMAN | |
| 1970 | Philip L. PILLSBURY | |
| 1971 | Paul SCHOLTEN | |
| 1972 | Xavier O. BARRIOS | |
| 1973 | Harold H. LINDNER | |
| 1974 | Brad COHN | |
| 1975 | John A. DRISCOLL | |
| 1976 | Robert L. PAVER | |
| 1976-77 | Edward T. KELLEY | |
| 1978 | Rafael A. SOLARI |